Tester feedback: “This has a firmer tip than other liquid liners I’ve tried, which makes it easy to get a precise line even with my shaky hands,” says contributing editor Deanna Pai, who wears contact lenses. “Plus, it’s never bothered my eyes, which are prone to dryness.”
Eyeliner type: liquid | Key ingredients: dimethicone, vitamin E | Shades: 1
Best Pencil Eyeliner: Jane Iredale Eye Pencil
Why we love it: The Jane Iredale Eye Pencil boasts a mineral-based formula infused with conditioning oils and waxes, ensuring a buttery-smooth application without tugging on delicate skin. Its rich, natural pigments deliver long-lasting color, while its versatile design makes it perfect for use beyond just the eyes. “It’s soft and hydrating for the delicate skin around the eye, enriched with meadowfoam seed oil, jojoba oil, and shea butter,” says Dr. Fahs. “It glides on effortlessly for an easy, sting-free application.”
Editor’s tip: It comes in six shades, including a stunning midnight blue shade that enhances blue tones in eyes to make them look even more vivid.
Eyeliner type: kohl | Key ingredients: jojoba oil, shea butter, mango oil | Shades: 6
Best for Waterline: Laura Mercier Caviar Tightline Eyeliner
Why we love it: While some waterline eyeliners can be harsh on sensitive eyes—they’re literally sitting in the space between your lashes and eyeball—the Laura Mercier Caviar Tightline Eyeliner is dermatologist-approved, ophthalmologist-tested, and safe for contact lens wearers, so you can enjoy long-lasting definition without irritation. “Infused with hydrating hyaluronic acid and dimethicone, it glides on smoothly while nourishing the delicate eye area,” says Dr. Fahs. The ultra-creamy formula gives you just enough time to blend before locking into a crease-proof finish that lasts up to 16 hours. Available in seven neutral shades, including two shimmer options gentle enough for sensitive eyes, this liner is the perfect mix of effortless application and serious staying power.
Editor’s tip: If you want to add a touch of shimmer to your liner look, use a fine, pearl-like shimmer like this eyeliner. Avoid chunky glitter, which can flake into the eyes and cause irritation.
Eyeliner type: gel | Key ingredients: vitamin E, hyaluronic acid | Shades: 7
Best Multipurpose Liner: Tower 28 OneLiner Lip Liner + Eyeliner + Cheek Pencil
Why we love it: If you’re looking for a do-it-all pencil that effortlessly transitions from lip liner to eyeliner to cheek color, the Tower 28 OneLiner Lip Liner + Eyeliner + Cheek Pencil is a must-have multitasker. The 2023 Best of Beauty Award winner “is fragrance-free, hypoallergenic, and free from harsh chemicals or preservatives—perfect for sensitive eyes and skin,” says Dr. Harden. “It glides on effortlessly and is packed with clean, hydrating ingredients like jojoba oil, shea butter, and sunflower seed oil.”